Collection: Mystery Boxes
The mystery is what's inside. The value is guaranteed.
Every standard mystery box is packed with a random mix from the same truckloads that stock our stores. Household goods, electronics, tools, toys, snacks, oddities — anything is possible. You don't know what's inside until you open it. That's the fun part.
Local pickup only
Shipping on these is sky-high, so we don't. Order online, then pick up at our Sheboygan store (2836 S Business Dr) or Wisconsin Rapids store (2211 8th St S) during regular hours. And there's a good reason to open it at the store:
The SDW Mystery Box Guarantee: the value or we swap it
- Buy your box.
- Open it at the store, after purchase, before leaving.
- We'll check the value with you, using current Amazon selling prices.
- Worth less than you paid? We swap it.
Expired food counts as $0. Once the box leaves the store, all sales are final. The guarantee applies only when the box is opened before leaving, and only to the standard mystery boxes on this page.
Who loves these
Treasure hunters. Groups who want to split the loot. Resellers looking for flips. Anyone who likes a game of chance and a deal.
Who should pass
Anyone who wants a specific item, expects perfection, or doesn't like random stuff. It's a mystery. There will be surprises, and some of them will be weird.
Looking for something else?
These are sold as-is with no value guarantee, but they're a lot of fun:
- Kids Squishy Mystery Boxes — squishies, fidgets and surprises for kids
- Mystery Jewelry Bags — 25+ pieces per bag
- Adult Only Mystery Boxes (18+)